Canyon Lakes Orthodontics

Invisalign vs Braces: Which Fits Teens and Adults?

Neither Invisalign nor braces is better for everyone. Braces stay on the teeth and handle the widest range of problems without daily effort from the patient. Clear aligners come out for meals and cleaning but must be worn most of the day and night, and they suit mild to moderate problems best.

By Canyon Lakes Orthodontics

Published · 7 minute read

A smiling woman holding a clear aligner

The honest answer to "Invisalign or braces?" is that it depends on the bite being corrected and on the person wearing the appliance. The American Association of Orthodontists puts it plainly: one appliance is not inherently better than another 1. This guide compares the two on the things that change daily life and the things that change the result, so you can go into a consultation knowing what to ask.

In this guide, "clear aligners" includes Invisalign. The practice-specific details are on our clear aligners and Invisalign page.

How do braces and clear aligners each move teeth?

Braces are small brackets bonded to the teeth and joined by a wire, which the orthodontist adjusts over time to shift the teeth and jaw 2. The brackets can be metal or tooth-colored, and some are placed behind the teeth 2. Our pages on metal braces and clear ceramic braces cover those options in detail.

Clear aligners are a series of custom-made, removable plastic trays 3. Each one is worn for a week or two before moving to the next in the series 3, and each moves the teeth a fraction of a millimeter 4. Small tooth-colored attachments are often bonded to some teeth so the trays can guide them into place 1. Aligners are prescription devices meant to be used under the supervision of a dentist or orthodontist 3.

Which problems does each one handle well?

This is the question that matters most, and it is where the two differ most.

Braces can treat a wide range of bite problems, including very bad bites and crooked teeth 5. Clear aligners are commonly used for mild to moderate problems, including crowded teeth, gaps between teeth and bite problems 3. More complex conditions may need braces or other treatment 3. The AAO adds that aligners may not work as predictably for severe bite problems, significant tooth rotations and large gaps 6.

That does not make braces the "serious" option and aligners the "easy" one. Where a case sits within what both appliances can treat, the choice comes down to lifestyle and preference. The AAO describes the decision as based on the goals of treatment and the patient's lifestyle needs 1.

How many hours a day do aligners need to be worn?

For most of the day. The FDA says aligners should be worn at least 20 hours a day or as directed by your dentist or orthodontist 3. The AAO's guidance is at least 22 hours a day 4. The two sources do not give the same figure, so the number to follow is the one your orthodontist prescribes for your case.

Wear time matters to the result. Treatment may not progress as intended when aligners are not worn as directed 3, and inconsistent wear can lengthen treatment or compromise the result 6. Braces do not depend on daily wear in the same way, because they are attached for the whole of treatment 5.

What changes about eating, drinking and cleaning?

Daily lifeBracesClear aligners
EatingAvoid hard, sticky, crunchy and chewy foods 1Trays come out to eat or drink 4
DrinksWater over soda, flavored water or sports drinks 1No soft drinks, flavored waters or sports drinks with trays in 1
CleaningBrush and floss around brackets and wires daily 1Trays come out for brushing and flossing 4
Watch out forA broken bracket or loose wire 1A lost or damaged tray 1

With braces, foods that are hard, sticky, crunchy or chewy can break a bracket or pull a wire loose 1. With aligners, the food list largely disappears but a new routine replaces it: trays come out to eat or drink and to brush and floss 4. Soft drinks, flavored waters and sports drinks should not be sipped with the trays in 1. Because they are removable, aligners can also be lost or damaged 1.

Either way, everyone in treatment brushes and flosses daily and wears retainers afterward 1. Retention is part of the plan with both appliances, and our retainers page explains how it works.

How often are appointments, and is one faster?

With braces, the AAO describes adjustment visits every 4 to 12 weeks, depending on the stage of treatment 5. With aligners, trays are changed at home, and periodic in-person visits check that the teeth are moving safely and as planned 3.

On speed, the evidence offered to patients is not consistent. One AAO page says braces tend to work faster than other treatments 5. Another says aligners can be faster than braces for many patients, depending on the complexity of the case 6. The FDA's guidance points to the case as what drives the timeline: how long treatment takes depends on how far the teeth need to move 3. Speed is not a good reason to pick either appliance on its own.

How does the choice differ for teens and adults?

For teenagers, a key question is wear time, because aligner results depend on consistent wear 6. Braces do not depend on anyone remembering them, because they stay attached for the whole of treatment 5. A parent who doubts that trays will stay in for most of the day should say so at the consultation; it is a clinical question, not a personal one.

The AAO notes that the near-invisible look of aligners is particularly valued by adults and teens who are self-conscious about braces 6. Adults who prefer braces have options too: healthy teeth can be moved at any age 2, and tooth-colored or behind-the-teeth brackets are available 2. Our adult orthodontics page covers the questions adults raise most.

Some discomfort comes with both. With braces, it occurs when they are placed or adjusted, and brackets and wires can irritate the inside of the mouth for a while 1. With aligners, it tends to come when switching to a new set of trays, and the AAO describes it as easily managed 1.

Does Invisalign cost more than braces?

Not at Canyon Lakes Orthodontics. Complete treatment with Invisalign and complete treatment with braces fall in the same fee range, typically $2,000 to $7,800. Where a case sits in that range depends on how complex it is and how long it is expected to take, not on which appliance is used. Your own fee is set out at the free consultation.

Insurance generally treats the two alike. Dental plans with orthodontic coverage usually cover braces and clear aligners equally 4, although each plan is different and coverage varies 4. Your benefits are reviewed with you at the first visit.

What should you ask at a consultation?

The AAO's advice is that the appliance matters far less than the skill of the person providing the treatment 1. Useful questions to bring:

  1. Which tooth movements does my case need, and can aligners make them predictably?
  2. If I choose aligners, what happens if my teeth stop tracking the plan?
  3. How often will I be seen, and what does the fee include?
  4. What will retention look like after treatment ends?

Comparing both options at Canyon Lakes Orthodontics

Canyon Lakes Orthodontics in San Ramon offers metal braces, clear ceramic braces and Invisalign, and Dr. Jenée Kaplan is a listed Invisalign provider, so the recommendation is not limited to one appliance. The first consultation is free and takes about 60 minutes, with an exam, a plan, and a review of cost and insurance benefits. Call (925) 735-1515 or request an appointment. Invisalign is a trademark of Align Technology, Inc.

Questions about this subject

Is Invisalign cheaper than braces?

Not at Canyon Lakes Orthodontics. Complete treatment with Invisalign and complete treatment with braces fall in the same fee range, typically $2,000 to $7,800, set by how complex the case is and how long it takes. Dental plans with orthodontic coverage usually treat the two the same way, though each plan differs4.

Is Invisalign faster than braces?

Not reliably. The American Association of Orthodontists describes braces as tending to work faster on one page and aligners as sometimes faster on another, depending on the case56. Treatment time depends on how far the teeth need to move3.

How many hours a day do you wear Invisalign?

Follow the schedule your orthodontist prescribes. The FDA says at least 20 hours a day or as directed3, and the AAO says at least 22 hours a day4.

Can adults get braces instead of Invisalign?

Yes. The ADA notes that healthy teeth can be moved orthodontically at any age, and that braces can be metal, tooth-colored or placed behind the teeth2.

Sources

  1. American Association of Orthodontists. Braces vs. Clear Aligners - Which is Best for You?. Accessed .
  2. American Dental Association (MouthHealthy). Braces. Accessed .
  3. U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Clear Dental Aligners. Accessed .
  4. American Association of Orthodontists. Clear Aligners. Accessed .
  5. American Association of Orthodontists. How Do Braces Work?. Accessed .
  6. American Association of Orthodontists. Clear Aligner Therapy. Accessed .

This article is general information, not a diagnosis or treatment recommendation for an individual. Bring your questions to an examination.

Ask how this applies to you

Canyon Lakes Orthodontics is on the east side of San Ramon. A consultation covers what is actually going on, which treatments apply, and what each one costs.